Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="trplnkl" data-source="post: 755428" data-attributes="member: 13254">I didn&#039;t say that illegal aliens had no rights, nor did I imply that they had no rights.Well, let us say that a person is seen driving on a public road, @ night, without lights. A minor violation of the law, but a violation none the less. The LEO pulls them over to issue a citation and the driver has no DL or ID of any kind. During the attempted conversation with the individual the officer becomes aware that the driver also does not speak or seem to understand english. During this otherwise routine stop, the officer tries to communicate with the driver without any appropriate responses. The officer then arrests the driver for driving in a manner that endangers life an property of others. When they arrive at the station house, the driver continues to be non communicative and is booked for impeding an investigation. While the driver is now jailed pending appearance before a judge, the LEO begins an investigation concerning the individual&#039;s status.Where has the Constitution been violated? &nbsp;How would you apply the 5th amendment to that situation?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="trplnkl, post: 755428, member: 13254"] I didn't say that illegal aliens had no rights, nor did I imply that they had no rights. Well, let us say that a person is seen driving on a public road, @ night, without lights. A minor violation of the law, but a violation none the less. The LEO pulls them over to issue a citation and the driver has no DL or ID of any kind. During the attempted conversation with the individual the officer becomes aware that the driver also does not speak or seem to understand english. During this otherwise routine stop, the officer tries to communicate with the driver without any appropriate responses. The officer then arrests the driver for driving in a manner that endangers life an property of others. When they arrive at the station house, the driver continues to be non communicative and is booked for impeding an investigation. While the driver is now jailed pending appearance before a judge, the LEO begins an investigation concerning the individual's status. Where has the Constitution been violated? How would you apply the 5th amendment to that situation? [/QUOTE]

Verification