Keep in mind something here. The banks were rather quiet when the idea of converting to an all private retirement system came up for discussion. The reason is that they didn't want to have to manage millions of small retirement accounts due to the expected implementation of caps on management fees making them unprofitable to manage because they couldn't get the big fees they wanted to handle them Furthermore the cold fact is that the brokerages and investment banks flat out do not want the small retail investor. The investment adviser I have had for many years recently left the firm he had been with for decades due to the fact that while they would not officially say they didn't want the small retail investor they treated the individual investor in a manner that clearly said "go away , go trade on line and good luck". So my adviser moved to one of the very few remaining firms that gladly welcomes the retail investor. Oh sure, anybody can open an online trading account and you will be most welcome especially welcomed by the short sellers, the option traders, the hedge funds etc.,standing there grinning like possums ready to take your money. Then as many of you have said there are those who want to keep their S.S. contribution but you know as well as I do they will spend it on the next instant gratification that comes along leaving them with nothing to retire on then run to the government for benefits. They want their cake and eat it too.