Why a 401(k) Will Yield You More Money Than a Pension

oldngray

nowhere special
And many people use it like a savings account and not a retirement account.
z-funny-93-1.jpg
 

Non liberal

Well-Known Member
Hypothetical example:

John begins UPS on Jan 1, 2020 and retires on Jan 1, 2055, at age 65.

Under the current pension plan, John's 35 years of service entitle him to roughly $70,000/yr (- taxes) beginning at age 65.

If John lives to be 85, he will have earned roughly $1.4 million(- taxes) in pension income during his lifetime.

-vs.-

If John fully invests his 401(k) from 2020 to 2055, he will have contributed roughly $787,500.
If John's investment grows at 5% for 35 years, his 401(k) account value at age 65 will be roughly $2,130,000 (that's nearly $1.4 million in earnings)

The real question you want to ask yourself is this:

Would I rather earn $1.4 million in taxable income by age 85, or would I rather have $1.4 million of taxable income in my account by age 65?

This is why I would rather have a 401(k) match over a pension.

These numbers get even sweeter when you factor in a company match for 35 years, holy :censored2:.

The pension is a freaking scam you guys. It's corporate welfare for dummies with no financial discipline.
I’d rather have a pension that is going to be there when I retire. Unlike my 401 k where 30k can just disappear because a democrat gets elected! But we never learn so…
 
Yeah, but then you don’t make anything so you would definitely want the pension over that.
The purpose of a 401k or an IRA is to give yourself a cost of living raise for retirement because you're pension does not offer one.


Everyone has a different risk tolerance and a different timeline.

It was almost horrifying to watch my 401k get shredded in half in 2008 and 2009
But fortunately I did not panic and left it alone and kept adding to it and now it's a pretty good amount.

Now I'm getting towards the end of my career so I have more money into the safe investments.
 

Non liberal

Well-Known Member
The purpose of a 401k or an IRA is to give yourself a cost of living raise for retirement because you're pension does not offer one.


Everyone has a different risk tolerance and a different timeline.

It was almost horrifying to watch my 401k get shredded in half in 2008 and 2009
But fortunately I did not panic and left it alone and kept adding to it and now it's a pretty good amount.

Now I'm getting towards the end of my career so I have more money into the safe investments.
How much is enough to put in your 401k? I have another question, how long do we get our pension for? Is it until we die, or just a set amount of years?
 
How much is enough to put in your 401k? I have another question, how long do we get our pension for? Is it until we die, or just a set amount of years?
You get it to you die but also you'll get less if you take out of survivorship clause for your spouse

As far as the answers how much is enough there's really no one fit answer for that.

Nobody knows how long you can do this job or how long you're going to live but the best thing I can tell you to do is to stay out of debt.
If you have no debt you need less money.
 

Over70irregs

Well-Known Member
The purpose of a 401k or an IRA is to give yourself a cost of living raise for retirement because you're pension does not offer one.


Everyone has a different risk tolerance and a different timeline.

It was almost horrifying to watch my 401k get shredded in half in 2008 and 2009
But fortunately I did not panic and left it alone and kept adding to it and now it's a pretty good amount.

Now I'm getting towards the end of my career so I have more money into the safe investments.
Well, maybe not.
Funny. People that get snowed on politics just keep being lost in wilderness.
 

Up In Smoke

Well-Known Member
We passed a 5.5T dollar tax cut without paying for it. We printed over 9T in treasuries, passed out 6T unemployment, PPP and SBA loans without oversight. Plenty of fingers in this mess.
 
Top