I’m sorry it’s difficult to talk to some people with such low intellect. You offer nothing in the way of solutions, only talking points.
In any negotiation, you have to remember there’s two sides and there’s a good chance the side you’re fighting against has a lot more support, so you really have to come to the table with a good argument and facts and numbers. The vast majority of people in that state will not care about someone’s dues not being taken out of your check they will figure if they want to be in the union. They will find a way to pay them. On the other hand, you will have a lot more support from people who think management is harassing people in order to break the union and caused labor strife. It might be a good way to make the whole bill go away, since it seems like they may have jumped the shark.
Anything short of that is a waste of time and childish.