Suit: UPS barred Muslim workers from praying at Mendota Hts. facility and fired them

over9five

Moderator
Staff member
A similar situation:

In fact, Islamic scholars generally agree that while prayers command high priority, they can be missed or performed later in extenuating circumstances.

“Employers have the right to protect themselves. Unfortunately, there are Muslims who abuse the system,” said Imam Yahya Hendi, president of Clergy Without Borders, an interfaith organization in Washington, D.C.

Hendi said that it was un-Islamic to accept pay for work one did not perform, and chastised the fired Hertz workers for making Islam seem “complicated” and “inadaptable to America.”

“If Muslims can do it on their own time, this is the idea,” said Zulfiqar Ali Shah, executive director of the North American Fiqh Council, a group of religious leaders who offer guidance on Islamic law.

“If there’s a conflict between prayer and work, the Muslims should accommodate to work,” said Shah.
For U.S. Muslims, Work-Time Prayer a Struggle | HuffPost
Gee, common sense!
 

Turdferguson

Just a turd
The article did not state how many times they prayed at work. Only that they must pray 5 times a day.
Said they couldn't pray as needed, not required.

"Abdullahi Dahir and Abdifatah Hassan said they had been allowed to pray as needed while at work "
A need is different than a requirement
 

Catatonic

Nine Lives
They pray at specific times during the day. The article made no mention that these employees only worked one specific shift.

Salah times - Wikipedia
Five daily prayersEdit

The five daily prayers are obligatory (fard) and they are performed at times determined essentially by the position of the Sun in the sky. Hence, salah times vary at different locations on the Earth.

FajrEdit
Fajar begins at subh saadiq -- true dawn or morning twilight, when the morning light appears across the full width of the sky -- and ends at sunrise.

Dhuhr (midday)Edit
Main article: Dhuhr
The Dhuhr prayer starts after the sun passes its zenith, and lasts almost 20 min (approx) before Asr. It's better to say the salah in between 2 hours after the Azan has been announced from Mosque.

Shia (Jafari madhab) differs regarding end of dhuhr time. Per all major Jafari jusrists, end of dhuhr time is about 10 minutes before sunset, the time that belongs exclusively to asr prayer. Dhuhr and asr time overlaps, apart from first 5 minutes of dhuhr, which is exclusively delegated for it. Asr prayer cannot be offered before dhuhr in the dhuhr time...

Asr (afternoon)Edit
Main article: Asr
The Asr prayer starts when the shadow of an object is the same length as the object itself (or, according to Hanafi fiqh, twice its length) plus the shadow length at Dhuhr, and lasts till sunset. Asr can be split into two sections; the preferred time is before the sun starts to turn orange, while the time of necessity is from when the sun turns orange until sunset.

Shia (Jafari madhab) differs regarding start of asr time. Per all major Jafari jusrists, start of asr time is about 5 minutes after the time of sun passing through zenith, that time belongs exclusively to dhuhr prayer. Time for dhuhr and asr prayers overlap, but the dhuhr prayer must be offered before asr, except the time about 10 minutes before sunset, which is delegated exclusively to asr. In the case that the mentioned time is reached, asr prayer should be offered first (ada - on time) and dhuhr (kada - make up, late) prayer should be offered after asr.

Maghrib (sunset)Edit
Main article: Maghrib
The Maghrib prayer begins when the sun sets, and lasts till the red light has left the sky in the west.

Isha'a (night)Edit
Main article: Isha'a
The Isha'a prayer starts when the red light is gone from the western sky, and lasts until the rise of the "white light" (fajar sadiq) in the east. The preferred time for Isha'a is before midnight, meaning halfway between sunset and sunrise.
Sounds like something a nomadic society would come up with.
The times of prayer is flexible.
 

PT Car Washer

Well-Known Member
I have read on here most areas don't give handlers breaks other than to use the restroom.
And if you do have to use the restroom during the sort you are criticized for perhaps having a medical condition or being childish. "Any adult should be able to hold it for a couple hours." Or "don't drink so many fluids before work". True story.
 

MAKAVELI

Well-Known Member
And if you do have to use the restroom during the sort you are criticized for perhaps having a medical condition or being childish. "Any adult should be able to hold it for a couple hours." Or "don't drink so many fluids before work". True story.
Tell them it's their choice. Either allow me to use the restroom or allow me to whip it out on the belt and allow me to relieve myself.
 
Top