Not necessarily.
The Western Conference of Teamsters Pension Trust (WCTPT) has advantages that other pensions do not have. The WCTPT is the largest multi-employer pension in the country with over $50B in assets. It covers 223,000 active participants with more than 1400 employers in 13 States. They bring in over $2.5B in contributions per year. Compare that to the UPS/IBT pension fund with only 65,000 active participants.
The WCTPT lost between 9% and 12% in 2022, but still maintained a credit balance. This means they took in more in contributions and investments than it paid out in benefits and administrative costs.
They have so much of a credit balance, they granted a 33% pension bonus for 2021-2023 to members. They increased the accrual from 1.2% to 1.6% for those years.
They also expects to have huge credit balances in the years to come. I do think that their investment strategy helps, but is not the only factor.
It has PT employees paying into the fund, most of whom will quit and never receive that money. Free money to the pension fund. UPS pays 14/hr in contributions into the WCTPT, and may get a little more this contract. Compare that to the New England Fund, which gets $6.20 per hour in contributions. More than double. Yes, the New England fund was raised to $11.15/hr this contract, but still almost $3/hr less in contributions than the Western. The figures are not calculated yet, but that $14/hr could go up a little.
If every pension fund received $14/hr in contributions, we would all be sitting pretty. But, I do not blame the West for getting those contributions. More power to them. I am glad for them. But they are still going to get $300/mo increase in their pension every year of the contract, even if the contribution rate is not increased.
The WCTPT has the best pension because they receive more in contributions than anyone else. And this remains true even with this contract. They may not get a pension contribution increase, but they still receive the highest contribution rate of anyone else. Their investment strategy also helps a little. Although, they did lose money last year. But, more in, more paid out.
Here is their projected credit balance for the years to come. This will be their yearly net increase, over and above the $50B in the plan, after paying benefits and administrative fees. We should all be so lucky to get into that plan. They still have the best pension plan in the country, because they have the highest contribution rate.
View attachment 445101