If Upstate only wants 5.5 hours, then let him only get the 5.5 hours. If anybody want 8 hours that is up to that individual as well. Not everybody wants 8 hours and is willing to take actual. To each his/her own.
I would only have a problem with him getting paid 5.5 hours and had requested 8 hours, but since his supplement only guarantees 4 hours, then he beat that anyway.