The last time I was on the 9.5 list and then filed a grievance for being over a sup approached me and told me I should have let them know I wasn't going to make. In front of the union steward I told him, "I shouldn't have to let you know. You know what you sent me out with and you have the ability all day to see how I'm progressing. The ball's in your court." Steward agreed and I went about my merry way.
You are 100% correct. These Bafoons like to play stupid, and try and place the blame on us. A smart driver can beat them every time. If everyone in your center stuck together, and got on the 9.5 list, management would be crapping their pants every day. That would force them to lower dispatch, and put on more routes, or just pay the grievances. Personally, I don't ever want to work anywhere near 9.5 because that means I spent 10.5 at work, not including my drive to and from work.