Our local level hearings on T-S 9.5 grievances resulted in a 1-0-4 for the members. One case was awarded penalty pay as the employee was under 4 years, but had become a RPCD and moved to M-friend during the summer months only to be sucked back after ratification. The four that were deadlocked, the company's position is they didn't meet the 5 days same route id criteria. We presented the paid cases from 2015-18 and the Labor Manager said " That was the previous manager and someone is going to have to change my mind."