When UPS failed to get out of the Teamsters' multi-employer pension plans in 1997, they then wanted to at least Partition them. (I thought the funds were largely partitioned already, because your benefit was proportionately based on your personal work history and company contribution level.) UPS believed 60% of UPS contributions were going to non-UPSers. They wanted 100% of UPS contributions going to UPSers. APWA true believers took this 60% figure as gospel and have created a cult following around it, who look East, to where their oracles reside and walk amongst us still. Oddly, the 60% figure never changes from year to year, or from one pension plan to another, regardless of stock market ups and downs.
So now UPS proposes to buy its way out of Central States by paying its legally owed Withdrawal Liability. But the $4 billion-plus Withdrawal Liability payments do not earn Central States UPSers any new pension credits. In fact, most everyone is a bit worse off as the result of loosing any non-contributory Past Service Credit they were granted, and forfeiting any pension credit milestones they were working toward. Plus, UPSers will start from zero, with no years of vesting, in any new pension plan.
Withdrawal Liability is a debt owed by UPS to the Central States fund generally. The payment is *not* made on behalf of UPSers, like regular monthly contribution are. Only a portion of it, say 40%, will ultimately find its way into UPSers' future pension checks. This seems to go against everything UPS has been saying.
In addition, although Withdrawal Liability is strictly a corporate UPS debt, look for UPS to try to claim that it is part of our compensation, and that we should accept a lower pay and benefit package to offset the huge expense. Let's remember, the proposed idea of withdrawing from Central States is a UPS idea; and the debt is owed by UPS, not UPSers. In effect, UPS contracted with Central States to hold their pension contributions and invest them until UPSers retired. UPS "buys" retirement services for its full-timers from the Central States Trustees, just as it buys uniforms and uniform cleaning services for its automotive people from outside vendors. UPS either chose its pension provider/investor unwisely, or is the victim of bad luck in the stock market, take your pick. Either way, it's not the responsibility of rank and file UPSers to pay the debt in any way. Don't let them, or Teamsters negotiators, make you feel you are responsible. In a Defined Benefit plan, your promised pension isn't yours until you actually are approved for a pension by the trustees and start receiving your first monthly check. Until then it's UPS' responsibility.