I've been a part of UPS for over 43 years as a Driver, a Supervisor, a Manager in Operations and I.E., and finally a Retiree. Believe it or not, the same complaints, and bitches I read on this web site today are exactly the same ones employees expressed in the 60s, 70s, 80s, and 90s.]
This thought has also occurred to me recently--I have been around since the 70s, and have heard each of the comments/complaints. However, I do think there are some distinctions today.
1) When I was a package car driver, the part-timers made an excellent wage; and we still had the occasional slacker. However, this is now the norm--with the exception that now they don't have a clue, and they could care less. This is our pool of future drivers and management. However, since almost no driver goes into supervision any longer, you may as well say that this is our future management pool. Almost all the full time sups I work with came straight from part-time. I am fortunate in the fact that they have been around for a while, and are "old school". However, my boss doesn't even know what a twin-screw tractor is...
2) When I first moved from part time to package car driver, it was horrible; but I toughed it out, because I was so grateful to finally be full-time. (You left out another phrase from the past: "You are luck to have a job here--There are 100 people just waiting to take your place"). However, this summer we have had 3 new drivers quit--See labor pool above...
Here is another phrase from the past: "Where would this company be without the driver?" OR "If it wasn't for the driver, this company would have gone out of business years ago." OR "It always comes down to the driver to fix everyone else's screw ups." Given the quality of the labor pool, I think we may be able to eventually retire these phrases, because the level of dedication from us old timers is just not going to be there. Here is a dirty little secret--I don't think UPS is all that concerned about the CS pension plan fiasco, because they don't want us to retire. There is a sizeable amount of people like me (early 50s, 30+ years seniority), chomping at the bit to leave. I think down deep, the company knows that they could be hit hard by the mass exodus. They would rather have us broken down, bad attitude drivers, because in the end, we still have that brown blood that somehow gets the job done.
3) Yes, the complaints about overtime have been around for years. In the past though, there was a line that was not crossed--You didn't like the overtime, but if you got mad/worked harder, you could still get done at a decent time. It has now gotten to the point that it doesn't matter--There is no more personal life. Why run to get home at 8:30pm instead of 9:00pm? Your are just going to eat dinner and fall asleep in front of the TV... You say that people have a naural bias against work measurement. Guess what--I have always thought that whatever standards UPS has given to me were fair! I have never had a problem meeting/exceeding performance measurements. The problem is, IT IS NEVER ENOUGH!! Here is another Golden Oldie: "We are really in a bind today--Can you help us out?" The next thing you know, it is part of your job.