Saw The Pat Tillman Story last night. Very good film because it looked at the issue mainly from the Family's POV. No conspiracy theories and regardless of where you stand on foreign policy, war, etc. this film is worthwhile for anyone. Josh Brolin IMO was a great narrator for this film. Very Robert Redford like who I also think is a fantastic Narrator.
Also you see Pat and his brothers growing up as kids and you gain some appreciation there and the family neighbors talking about the boys was a bit entertaining is not a bit embarrassing for the mom in a humorous way. Yes there were some light hearted moments as well as some serious and of course sad moments too. All of Pat's immediate family were and spoke in the film about various events except Kevin. Other than some still photos and file footage, the only time Kevin was heard speaking in the film besides when Pat got married was when Kevin spoke before Congress in 2007'. As to why he didn't speak in the film, that seems to be an answer only Kevin himself knows.
The film does not prove any conspiracies nor IMO does it allege any either. If one wants too, certain events can be used in such ways but there are no hard facts given to prove that. Pat's death was from friendly fire that so often takes place in the Fog of War and as tragic as that was, it was really the post death events and actions that were the real tragedy and the family was the chief victim along with the truth.
Pat was not perfect and yet at the same time he was the all american boy and maybe that truth is Pat's legacy to the all american boy ideal. Yet, this film as much as it had a gov't angle even more so had a very human angle too it. Pat wasn't looking to be a hero and in fact the film shows clearly all the hero attention he got, he would have opposed and his wishes before death clearly recognized his death might be used in such way and he tired to prevent it. One is left wondering if Pat would have given the same speech that Lt. Commander Madison character gave to the Mrs. Barham character over tea about the horrors of war and resulting hero worship in the film "The Americanization of Emily"? Great film BTW just on the comedic duo of James Garner (Madison) and Julie Andrews (Emily). You'll see early on the comedy pairing for the later Victor/Victoria.
The Tillman film's greatest message was not the tragedy of war in itself but that in war very good, moral, decent people get killed and one is left to sit back and ponder, is/was the price paid at the end of the day really worth it? Each of us are left to answer that question for ourselves.
A week from tomorrow, Friday April 22nd will mark the 7 year anniversary of Pat's death and to Pat's wishes I won't celebrate him as a hero but I will be sad for our loss of a good human being!
RIP Pat!