Was it illegal? I really don't know. I do know WC laws are different state to state and change regularly (at least around here). '94 was a long time ago.
According to lawyer it was. Back then we had special IBM shipments and I was courier responsible for delivering them while station was doing sort. One of the locations was a storage unit. Unit door was in shadow so ice hadn't melted yet. I slipped to my knees three times trying to get door opened. Finally did, put boxes inside, shut the door, and turned to leave. Feet shot out from under me, landed fully on shoulder which popped like a gunshot. I started yelling for help, storage manager came out, saw arm dangling, started laughing. Found out from lawyer because I was on clock, New Mexico law, could only get workman's comp. But her actions were beyond my injury, were illegal according to lawyer. Threatening tone on phone, insisted I come in. Maybe I wouldn't have gotten anything, but experience dealing with FedEx over years is this: they don't like paying money for nothing. Their attitude is that if they push injured courier enough he'll "recover" quickly enough to get back to work. They want something for paying me for three weeks sitting around. She should have, and ultimately did, let me recover at home. Near end of three weeks started calling me daily, bullying tone, wanted to know when I'd be back. I was supposed to start physical therapy at end of three weeks, got my doctor to sign off on letting me return to work, as whole experience made me feel I was in jeopardy of losing my job. So yeah, if I had done what she wanted, and doctor had told me my arm wasn't healing properly due to lifting at work, that it would never be right, and if I had a crystal ball showing the direction company was headed with raises and pension, I would have sued. And I would have had a respected local doctor in his 60's telling them my boss called him up and pushed him(his words to me) to allow me to do light duty, and he ok'd it as long as I was extremely careful and did no lifting, which she immediately ignored.