So are you suggesting that the driver be allowed to bump someone off both the preload and metro so that he can get his 8 hours? All because the driver was unable to recite safety dribble? Doesn't seem quite fair, does it? I think taking a driver out of service for not knowing the safety dribble is over the top but I also think that the safety dribble is not that hard to learn and if it meant the difference between working or not I would take the time needed to learn the dribble, but that's just me.
My opinion is that the job is WAD, so therefore UPS can use us however they see fit. Just IMO.
Do I agree with being taken out of service for not spewing the 10s and 5s?
I do because we are supposed to be professional drivers that know more than the average driver. The 10s and 5s are , at least IMO, hardly the best way of learning the knowledge it's imparting, but they do have value.
And like you said, if a driver cannot save their job and learn the information (even if it means nothing to them), then should they be on the road in the first place as a top-paid, professional driver?
Originally I would have sided with the grumpy union type side, but the more I have learned, and applied them, it really isn't a big deal and does have value.