one reason people orginally like W. was he wasnt a great speaker, but when he did he was sincere and somewhat charming in a down country sort of way, he seemed like an everyday man, watched sports, worked on the ranch type thing
Obama can be a great orator when he knows whats going to be discussed, and he is well versed in his speach
to trully be presidential in speaking, you need to be sincere, quick, clear, consise, and inspirational.
Why do we remember FDR for Dec 7th 1941 is date that will live infamy, or there is nothing to fear but fear itself. or kennedy for saying we do not do things because they are easy we do them because they are hard or dont ask what your country can do for you but what you can do for your country.
They fit the guidlines quick, sincere,consise, and inspirational. those speaches led america through some hard and great times.
And in those terms, Mccain is just plain more presidential, Obama adds a lot of fluff to speaches that sound great, but blind people to what the subject at hand is