I was one of the attendees at the Louisville meeting and flew in for the occasion. I had a window seat on both legs of my arriving and departing flights and was treated to a great aerial view of the massive international UPS sorting operation there. Too bad tours weren't offered at the complex. I would have taken one.
At any rate, there's nothing like seeing what is actually happening with the movement by getting into the trenches, which is why I decided to attend this meeting. Phone calls and emails only take one so far. It was a privilege to meet the acting President, the Senior Vice President, the APWA attorney and the brave KY UPSers at the meeting.
I provide this account for those who are curious of what currently goes on at an APWA meeting. This account is mine only and others may have had a different experience in a dissimilar environment. Feeders gives a good summary of the events that day, and I'll offer up a few more details, although I'll leave the name of the hotel out and the involved Local Union. As Feeders noted, the adjoining conference room was rented by the involved Local Union and was well stocked with donuts, muffins, other assorted pastries, etc. Later in the APWA meeting, these expeditures were criticized as being a complete waste of dues money.
This conference room was believed to have been rented for two purposes. One was to create confusion. Just maybe an APWA meeting attendee would mistakenly walk into this meeting area and think the meeting was here and would be taken in by the free food. The second was an attempt to intimidate the APWA attendees who were in the APWA meeting room, by creating a boisterous environment next door, punctuated with moderately hostile banter and laughter. Just letting everybody know that they are next door.
The meeting was slated to begin at 10:00 AM and the militants were, for the most part, in place by 9:00 AM, making their presence felt. As the APWA meeting time drew closer, the militants gradually became increasingly noisier and hung out in the lobby, creating a "picket line" of sorts, so APWA attendees would have to run the gauntlet to get inside the proper conference room. Kudos to the hearty souls who braved the "picket line" and the potential diversion set up next door, with the free food sitting there.
The meeting did not start on time as the militants streamed in. The President, attempted to start the meeting, but a boisterous ruckus was coming to a head. One shouted out, if the teamsters are out, there will be no union for a year, which was later debunked as false by the APWA attorney because it is a simple replacement. Anyway, the involved Local Union President was a nuisance making attempts to disrupt the meeting, even though the APWA President graciously offered to let him ask the attorney questions, which must have been unfinished business from a past meeting. One militant was asked to leave after asking loaded and provocative questions and the off-duty police officer had to show him the door, but also had to show him his badge. On his way out, the militant whined about the poor treatment potential members get for asking questions. The security guard later complained these people don't understand the difference between private and public property. On private property, the unruly are trespassing.
A couple more militants took turns approaching the podium and conference table to jeer the APWA President, Senior Vice President and the attorney. It is believed the militants wanted to give the "union busting" attorney a hard time. One had a cup of water with him and splashed it on both the Senior Vice President and the attorney, while demanding they go back to their right-to-work state in NC and to get out of KY, before stomping off. Presentation materials were also wadded up into paper balls and thrown at the Senior Vice President or ripped in half and thrown into the air. All three stood up stoically to the militants. They did not flinch and were poised and polite, which made the militants really look stupid. One militant even had the audacity to bring his kid with him and other militants actually criticized him for it. One woman who gave the impression of supporting the APWA, pulled out her camera and started taking pictures. Finally, one militant said something like, "whoever stays here is a scab," while looking around the room for them, and just like that they all left, including the woman with the camera. The militants went back outside into the lobby and loudly hung out in the lobby and their conference room before gradually leaving the hotel. Another woman stayed as the meeting was restarted and tried the same tactic of asking a list of provocative questions before stomping off herself. All-in-all, the ruckus wasted about 20-25 minutes of meeting time. Later as the meeting was finally settling in and as the militants were leaving, one slapped on the conference room window to send one final message.
Once the meeting was actually started, the APWA President gave about a 40 minute presentation. The materials, which were presented, are similar to the information on the APWA website. From there it was a question and answer session.
A few of the main highlights of the Q and A sesson included points made by the APWA attorney. He claimed he was not a "union busting attorney," but instead he said "people bust unions" - meaning the actual employees who want to get rid of or change the bargaining agent. One attendee compared him to a divorce attorney, which was a good analogy. He said his main job is to inform employees what their rights are under the law. He will also represent employees who are harassed for wanting another union by filing unfair labor practice charges with the NLRB, as a duty of fair representation case.
Furthermore, all UPS employees around the country will be designated as one national bargaining unit for representational purposes. Local bargaining units like we have now will be a thing of the past, if this campaign is successful. Once 30% of the employees sign a petition for decertification, an election can be held. Once an election is held, only 50% of those who vote for decertification are needed to win the election. From there, it will be a process of certifying the APWA as bargaining agent and at this point the APWA becomes a real union, instead of the 501(c)(5) nonprofit status it has now. From what I understand, as much of this process as possible will take place online and via mail-in ballots. The meeting attendees liked the idea of the online petition forms and the mail-in ballots because it will reduce the opportunities for voter intimidation. The APWA is trying to lay the groundwork now for it's goal of a hopefully smooth transition as bargaining agent in 2008.
So in short, I'm glad I went. Even though the meeting was set against a chaotic backdrop of hostile crowd psychology, it didn't stop me and others from attending. It was worth seeing where the movement is going first hand and if others have the opportunity, one should try to attend a meeting when the APWA comes to town. It will take some courage to attend a meeting, but I just remind myself of the Iraqi people who recently voted in their own democratic elections.