President Trump

oldngray

nowhere special
Since I feel sorry for you...

Still, let’s say Mueller sticks to his guns, refusing to disclose the memo’s description of his jurisdiction and insisting that Judge Ellis is entitled to see only the thin Manafort paragraphs that have already been revealed. If Ellis reacts by dismissing the indictment, any appeal would go to the Fourth Circuit, which after eight years of Obama has turned sharply to the left.
Who would send it back to the same lower court facing the same judge.

Or didn't you read that part?
 

floridays

Well-Known Member
Since I feel sorry for you...

Still, let’s say Mueller sticks to his guns, refusing to disclose the memo’s description of his jurisdiction and insisting that Judge Ellis is entitled to see only the thin Manafort paragraphs that have already been revealed. If Ellis reacts by dismissing the indictment, any appeal would go to the Fourth Circuit, which after eight years of Obama has turned sharply to the left.
I love your copy and paste, why did you stop? I told you the remedies for not responding to the judges order, I have no idea how the judge will respond since they have responded. I understand everything in your last sentence and knew it before you did your copy and past. The difference between you and me is I have an understanding of how this works. Without copy and paste.
 

bbsam

Moderator
Staff member
No, they couldn't, it was ordered by a Federal Judge, failure to comply is contempt. The only way out was to ask for a stay of the order while they petitioned an appeal court for a ruling. You got that? The ball was totally in the Judge's hands on dismissal. He ordered, they respond or get a higher court to overrule the judge.

I love your copy and paste, why did you stop? I told you the remedies for not responding to the judges order, I have no idea how the judge will respond since they have responded. I understand everything in your last sentence and knew it before you did your copy and past. The difference between you and me is I have an understanding of how this works. Without copy and paste.

Now you’re just lying.
 

floridays

Well-Known Member
ou missed it. Flori said Mueller had no choice and would be held in contempt.[/QUOTE]
That is a lie, I said he would have to ask for a stay of the order to appeal.
 

floridays

Well-Known Member
Irrelevant anyway since Mueller already gave the judge the unredacted memo.
He lied about what I said, I listed Mueller's remedies in court. I despise a piece of :censored2: that put's words in my mouth or changes my words. You are correct Mueller complied, he knew the road he had to travel if he didn't.@bbsam
 

bbsam

Moderator
Staff member
ou missed it. Flori said Mueller had no choice and would be held in contempt.
That is a lie, I said he would have to ask for a stay of the order to appeal.[/QUOTE]
According to Andrew McCarthy (and me), the judge simply dismisses the case and Mueller appeals.
 

bbsam

Moderator
Staff member
No, they couldn't, it was ordered by a Federal Judge, failure to comply is contempt. The only way out was to ask for a stay of the order while they petitioned an appeal court for a ruling. You got that? The ball was totally in the Judge's hands on dismissal. He ordered, they respond or get a higher court to overrule the judge.
This is your lie. Or you just don’t know what you are talking about which seems more likely.
 

floridays

Well-Known Member
That is a lie, I said he would have to ask for a stay of the order to appeal.
According to Andrew McCarthy (and me), the judge simply dismisses the case and Mueller appeals.[/QUOTE]
No, the judge is not dismissing the case, he want's an answer, your reading comprehension is lacking.
If the judge was going to dismiss he would have told them to produce the document or he would dismiss. Could have been solved that day. He wanted more information to give a legitimate ruling. The other hack, went on what was produced, without total inquiry. If the judge is satisfied with what he ordered, he is ready to proceed. They responded, he will proceed. Stay in pkg delivery.
 

bbsam

Moderator
Staff member
According to Andrew McCarthy (and me), the judge simply dismisses the case and Mueller appeals.
No, the judge is not dismissing the case, he want's an answer, your reading comprehension is lacking.
If the judge was going to dismiss he would have told them to produce the document or he would dismiss. Could have been solved that day. He wanted more information to give a legitimate ruling. The other hack, went on what was produced, without total inquiry. If the judge is satisfied with what he ordered, he is ready to proceed. They responded, he will proceed. Stay in pkg delivery.[/QUOTE]
No. McCarthy said clearly that if Mueller refused to comply then Ellis would dismiss. There is no mention of contempt or a stay.

I don’t know if you are or ever were in package delivery. I can say with certainty you don’t belong in litigation.
 
Top