My building (225 drivers) has been on Telematics for over 2 years now, so I have plenty of experience dealing with it first hand.
In that 2+ years we have had a grand total of one Telematics-related termination for dishonesty. The driver scanned a NDA to a business as "closed" at 10:26 when he was actually several blocks away, and then made the actual delivery 10 minutes later after the commit time. And it wasnt the Telematics data itself that got the guy fired, it was the fact that he lied and wound up admitting that lie when questioned about it.
If Telematics is coming to your center and this is the kind of stuff that you do....you will have to stop. But if this isnt the kind of stuff that you do....then you truly dont have anything to worry about. You arent going to get fired for showing up on the bulkhead door report and you arent going to get fired for showing up on the seatbelt report and you arent going to get fired because you have more "backing events" then some guy in a cubicle thinks you should have.
I can say that Telematics has actually vindicated me on two occasions. I had a customer in a trailer park call in a complaint on me for "speeding" thru the park. The speed limit is 10MPH. They pulled the Telematics report and it showed that I was going.....10MPH. Case closed. I also made a delivery to a house where the FedEx guy who had been there earlier had gone down the driveway and backed his truck onto the customers lawn in order to get turned around. He would up tearing the lawn all to hell. I parked at the curb and walked the stop off. The customer came home, found packages on the porch from FedEx and UPS, and called both companies to find out who tore up the lawn. The Telematics report clearly showed that I parked on the street and did not back at all, which would have made it physically impossible for me to be the guilty party.
Bottom line; if you have nothing to hide, then you will soon forget that Telematics is even there.
Here is my take on telematics, and a real world example of our center. Originally I wouldn't post things like this because I'm sure there are people reading this site, that have SOME knoweldge of this event.
Driver was accused and had telematics report that he was leading the center in backs per day/excessive backs so they deemed. I believe he had 20-40 per day, while the company wanted him under 10 and said there were many during the day he could avoid.
The long, winding telematics reports of course are for all to see right on the boards in the center. There are several areas of the center with these reports.
Long story short, a week later the said driver was down to 10-20 backs per day, which was acceptable. In honor of this, the center took it upon itself to announce in a PCM that the driver reduced his backs from 20-40 to 10-20. They explained his issues with the problem in detail , fully quoting all telematics reports for every day, and made an example of the said driver.
Now to some people they would look at this as noteworthy and important. IN my opinion, it is no one elses business who has "report" problems and who doesn't. I can't speak for others but to me, it would be frankly embarrasing, because most of the other drivers were jeering and harrasing the said driver , mostly jokingly. It was pretty awkward, in hindsight.
Is this what the center is trying to do? Embarrass drivers who have production or "telematics report" issues? Is that really ethical